senseable city lab.

Breathing Disparity

senseable city lab.

The Bronx and New York

The Bronx has the second smaller population among the five boroughs of New York City. With 1,332,650 inhabitants, its population is similar to Manhattan’s.

senseable city lab.

Low-Income Population

However, the Bronx has the highest share of low-income population among NYC’s boroughs—almost three times the share of low-income population in Queens.

senseable city lab.

Non-White Population

And 89% of the population in the Bronx are non-white, predominantly Hispanic and Black population.

senseable city lab.

Asthma Emergency Visits

The percentage of asthmatic adults hospitalized in the Bronx is 2.5 times higher than the average level in NYC.

senseable city lab.

senseable city lab.

Trips to the Bronx

We used cell phone big data in NYC to uncover individuals’ movement patterns and discover how they move in and out of the Bronx borough.

senseable city lab.

Mean PM2.5 Exposure

We coupled people’s mobility patterns with hyper-local air pollution data (particulate matter 2.5) to measure personal exposure, by socio-economic groups, for each street of the Bronx. We discovered that people from Hispanic- and Black-majority communities are much more exposed than any other groups, while high-income communities are less exposed.

senseable city lab.

Environmental Disparity

We then measured and mapped disparities for each street of the Bronx. Highest exposure disparities cluster around regional road arteries. Additionally, streets with high exposure disparities do not coincide with those with high average personal exposures and only partially coincide with those with high air pollution levels. This suggests that existing methods to regulate air quality and lower personal exposure might not mitigate exposure disparities between income or race/ethnicity groups. 

Income

Race

senseable city lab.

Environmental Disparity

Finally, we observed that people from low-income and Hispanic-majority communities suffer the most within-group variation in particulate matter 2.5 exposure. The plots demonstrate the relative disparity measure on all Bronx streets calculated for each group, where exposure disparities are higher within race/ethnicity groups than within income groups.

Income

Race

Breathing Disparity

Publication


Testi, I., Wang, A., Paul, S., Mora, S., Walker, E., Nyhan, M., Duarte, F., Santi, P., Ratti, C. (2024). Big mobility data reveals hyperlocal air pollution disparities. Nature Cities.



Team


Carlo Ratti Director, Senseable City Lab


Research

Iacopo Testi Lead

An Wang Lead

Sanjana Paul

Simone Mora

Fábio Duarte

Paolo Santi


Erica Walker Brown University

Marguerite Nyhan University College Cork


Website

Marco Valli Lead

Fábio Duarte

Martina Mazzarello

Jingrong Zhang


Press


The material on this website can be used freely in any publication provided that


1. it is duly credited as a project by the MIT Senseable City Lab


2. a PDF copy of the publication is sent to senseable-press@mit.edu



In collaboration with


Center for Climate-Smart Transportation, Johns Hopkins University


NYC Office of Technology and Innovation (OTI)

NYC Department of Health

NYC Department of Citywide Administrative Services (DCAS)


Spectus Social Impact